I have often been forced down the lawyer path of giving construction dispute advice with the preamble of β€œon the one hand, and on the other”. I was thus somewhat surprised to read that Helen Garthwaite (23 June, page 80) has the confidence to take a firm view.

Garthwaite was pleading the case for judge mediators and had noted that β€œinterestingly some mediation clauses specify that the mediator shall be … a lawyer”. This, she suggested, was because clients β€œlove” judges.

Well, β€œinterestingly”, her article began with the word β€œcynics” and she should therefore not be surprised that the interpretation I put on this β€œlawyer-preference” is not that clients value judges but that lawyers, having lost income to arbitration or adjudication, are seeking to embed themselves in mediation and thus guarantee their pensions.

John Wilding, John Wilding & Co

Topics