Chris Ryan respects the endurance of Newcastleās Victorian terraces, but reckons Foster + Partnersā Peterborough academy just canāt hack the pace of history
Iām more into traditional buildings and I was brought up in Newcastle, so I love Greyās Monument and the rest of Grey Street in Newcastle. People donāt take enough time looking at the old cities like Newcastle and Liverpool. They miss a lot of the detail. But I like to spend five minutes looking at the details here as I walk from the monument down to the quayside. Everything on the street has been cut from solid pieces of stone. There are carvings - on the walls of old banks and into the doors of buildings. It was all built on the back of the ports and of slavery, really. Itās stood the test of time - unlike most of the stuff we are throwing up these days.
I spend a lot of time in America so I hate the strip malls that they put up over there - they try to make them look like Mediterranean villages by covering them with wood. If you donāt feel sick looking at it, thereās something wrong with you.
But a particular building that has stuck out recently is one of those academy schools in Peterborough. Iāve been visiting a lot of schools recently to give talks. This particular one was designed by Foster + Partners and cost Ā£50m.
It is full of pods and open spaces. There are too many distractions and itās a cross between a mall and an art gallery. Itās like a large, glass-fronted maze. It obviously didnāt work as a place of learning because it had a resident policeman onsite.
When I compare it with the very established private schools Iāve also been visiting, I think it misses the point. I donāt think itās a place that will last more than 200 years like them - even at its huge cost. It doesnāt sit well with me at all.
Wonder
Grey Street is part of the classical Grainger Town in Newcastle, built by developer Richard Grainger between 1824 and 1841. Most of the four-storey buildings are built of granite and have many vertical dormers, domes, turrets and spikes. It was recently voted the best street in the UK in a Radio 4 poll.
Blunder
The Thomas Deacon academy in Peterborough was built in 2007 by Laing OāRourke to designs by Foster + Partners and Buro Happold. The school, nicknamed the āblancmange,ā is divided into six lobes linked by footbridges. It achieved notoriety on opening for having no playground.
Chris Ryan is a former SAS soldier, best known for travelling from Iraq to Syria on foot after his mission ended in disaster. He has written severalnovels and presented the Sky series, How Not to Die
No comments yet